A poignant reminder this week that during this COVID period, the Courts will still strictly apply the time limits and requirements for applying to have a statutory demand set aside.
In CPR Solutions Mackay Pty Ltd v Zammit Earthmoving Pty Ltd, the respondent served a creditor’s statutory demand pursuant to section 559E of the Corporations Act 2001 (Corporations Act) demanding payment of $244,824.04.
Pursuant to section 459G of the Corporations Act, a company may apply to the Court for an order setting aside a statutory demand. However, the application must be made within 21 days of the demand being served.
Section 459G(3)(b) of the Corporations Act provides an application to set aside the demand is made only if within the 21 days statutory period, a copy of the application, and a copy of the supporting affidavit, are served on the person who served the demand on the company.
Unfortunately for the applicant, whilst the application and supporting affidavits had been filed within the 21-day statutory period (having been filed on the twentieth day), the acting registrar could not set a return date for the hearing due to the altered Court arrangements as a consequence of COVID-19.
The applicant’s solicitor served an unsealed copy of the application and supporting affidavit along with a receipt from the Court confirming the documents had been filed on the twentieth day following service of the statutory demand. The respondent’s solicitors refused to accept that formal service had been effected until they received sealed copies of the application with the Court number and return date for the hearing to set aside the demand.
The Supreme Court had to determine whether service of the application was effected for the purposes of section 459(3(b) of the Corporations Act when the application did not have the date of filing stamp and the receipt stamp, did not contain a Court number, a Court seal or a return date. Justice Crow determined that the document served was not a sufficient copy of what was filed for the purpose of section 459G(3) because the document omitted the date stamp and the receipt stamp.
Accordingly, the application to set aside the statutory demand was dismissed. The consequence is that the Applicant failed to comply with the statutory demand, the Applicant is deemed insolvent and the Respondent is entitled to apply for the Applicant to be wound up in insolvency.
Whilst the decision is harsh, it is an important reminder to be vigilant in ensuring that you strictly comply with the requirements of the Corporations Act when applying to have a statutory demand set aside.
If you have been served with a statutory demand, make sure you seek expert legal advice regarding your options early. Speak to the team at Axia Litigation Lawyers today because – Every move matters!
Contact Axia Litigation Lawyers direct and speak with an expert today.
Axia Litigation Lawyers are experts in dispute resolution and litigation.
Contact us today to understand how you can effectively and efficiently reach a resolution in your matter.
After multiple attempts at trying to find reliable counsel in Australia to act on an advisory basis to our firm, we found ourselves feeling reassured and feel as though we have gained a solid ally with Axia Litigation.
Thank you for your outstanding help & I couldn't be happier with the help AXIA have given me.
I have no hesitation in recommending them. They were always very informative and answered all of my questions and always kept me in the loop and well informed of my progress.
After my initial consultation with Axia Litigation Lawyers, I felt the tension and stress fall away. They were both compassionate and understanding of my case and were diligent and thorough in their work ethic.
Adam and staff have been very helpful throughout the whole process. Very happy with the service and final outcome.
Axia were competent, diligent and excellent to work with.
The team at Axia Litigation were first class, when guiding us through two consecutive legal matters. We received regular communication, with each of the legal steps explained in full.
We have used Axia Legal on two occasions over the last three years with great success and I am happy to recommend Adam Brown from Axia Legal
Axia Lawyers are an excellent litigation firm that handle cases in a professional manner and pay attention to details. The customer service was outstanding, I would highly recommend this firm.