A recent Fair Work Commission decision highlights the need for employers to take care when terminating an employee following an extended probationary period.

In Natasha-Anne Werner v St Michael’s Association [2020] FWC 2896, the employer had extended the employee’s 6-month probation period for a further 3 and a half months. On the last day of the extended probationary period, the employee was dismissed. The employer wrongly thought that the employee was not protected from unfair dismissal because the employee was terminated before the end of the extended probationary period.

This is a common mistake.

The employee was still protected from unfair dismissal because the employee had worked for longer than the minimum employment period under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FWA).

Under the FWA, an employee must be employed for a minimum of 6 months (or 12 months if the employer is a small business with fewer than 15 employees) to make an unfair dismissal claim.

An extension to the probationary period under the employment contract does not extend the minimum employment period under the FWA.

In finding that the employee had been unfairly dismissed, the Fair Work Commission considered that the employer’s whole approach was misguided. Rather than correctly considering whether the employee’s performance was poor enough to warrant termination, it wrongly asked whether her performance was good enough to retain her job.

The dismissed employee was awarded $8,788.64.


Employers should take care when terminating an employee following an extended probationary period.

Extending the probationary period does not extend the minimum employment period under the FWA, therefore, an employer could still find themselves subject to an unfair dismissal claim if they do not comply with their obligations under the FWA.

If you are unsure about your obligations when terminating the employment of an employee, or if you believe you have been unfairly dismissed, contact Axia Litigation Lawyers today for expert advice, because – Every Move Matters!

Want to know more?

Contact Axia Litigation Lawyers direct and speak with an expert today.

You might also like

Dealing with a dispute & need expert advice?

Axia Litigation Lawyers are experts in dispute resolution and litigation.

Contact us today to understand how you can effectively and efficiently reach a resolution in your matter.

We have used Axia Legal on two occasions over the last three years with great success and I am happy to recommend Adam Brown from Axia Legal

Cara R,

Axia Lawyers are an excellent litigation firm that handle cases in a professional manner and pay attention to details. The customer service was outstanding, I would highly recommend this firm.

Jodi B,

After multiple attempts at trying to find reliable counsel in Australia to act on an advisory basis to our firm, we found ourselves feeling reassured and feel as though we have gained a solid ally with Axia Litigation.

Portland Maritime,

Adam and staff have been very helpful throughout the whole process. Very happy with the service and final outcome.

Dale G,

Thank you for your outstanding help & I couldn't be happier with the help AXIA have given me.

Steven C,

The team at Axia Litigation were first class, when guiding us through two consecutive legal matters. We received regular communication, with each of the legal steps explained in full.

Premier Box,

After my initial consultation with Axia Litigation Lawyers, I felt the tension and stress fall away. They were both compassionate and understanding of my case and were diligent and thorough in their work ethic.

Liz W,

I found Jennifer and the team at Axia extremely thorough and knowledgeable with my recent copyright case. I only wish other legal firms acted with such integrity. We will definitely engage their services if required in the future.

Anthony S, Platinum Residential Designer Homes

Axia were competent, diligent and excellent to work with.

Sharon D,

I have no hesitation in recommending them. They were always very informative and answered all of my questions and always kept me in the loop and well informed of my progress.

Greg P,